Pittsford: Mature Hardwoods — When Trimming Beats Removal

View fullsize

Pittsford has lots of mature hardwoods—oaks, maples, and beeches that frame driveways and stone walls. Not every “big tree” needs to come down. In many cases, selective trimming (done to ANSI A300 standards) keeps trees safer, healthier, and better looking—without losing the shade and character you paid for.

When trimming is the smarter move

• Overextended limbs, not a failing tree
  If risk is tied to specific limbs over a driveway, roof, or service drop, crown reduction and selective thinning target those limbs instead of removing the whole tree. Reduction cuts are made back to laterals (not stubs), preserving structure and leaf area.

• Heavy, “sail-like” crowns before the wind or snow season
  Pittsford gets wind events and wet-snow loads. Thinning (done correctly—no “lion-tailing”) reduces end-weight and sail effect, which research shows can lower movement and damage during storms.

• Where decay is limited and the branch collar is intact, proper pruning helps trees compartmentalize wounds and keep decay from spreading—especially when cuts are made at the right place and size.

• Clearance needs (cars, walks, roofs) without topping
  You want clearance, not butchering. Topping (heading cuts to arbitrary lengths) is explicitly not acceptable because it invites decay and weak regrowth. Trimming to laterals (reduction) preserves the tree’s form and strength.

When removal still makes sense

• Severe structural defects (e.g., extensive decay, root failure, large dead leaders).

• Species/condition mismatch (e.g., catastrophic ash decline).

• Risk outweighs value near high-target areas when mitigation isn’t realistic.

What “good trimming” actually looks like

• Defined objectives: crown cleaning (dead/diseased), crown reduction (to laterals), crown raising for clearance; no topping. ci.vallejo.ca.us

• Respect the branch collar (no flush cuts); correct cut placement speeds closure and limits decay. Cornell Cooperative Extension

• Avoid lion-tailing (stripping inner foliage and leaving tufts); it weakens structure and increases the risk of failure. What's Happening Around Florida

• Right amount: removing too much live wood at once stresses mature trees. Trim conservatively and phase work if needed.

Seasonal/timing notes for Pittsford

• Late winter/early spring is often ideal for structural pruning of hardwoods (trees are dormant; wounds close as growth starts). Remove deadwood anytime. Avoid paint/sealers.

• Storm prep: schedule reductions/thinning before the windy/wet-snow season to reduce emergency calls later.

  Our process for mature hardwoods

  1. Assessment: species, defects, targets, site access.

  2. Plan: define objectives (clearance, risk reduction, view, storm prep).

  3. Execute: reduction to laterals, selective thinning, crown cleaning—no topping.

  4. Clean finish: chips hauled; logs optional; stump work if applicable.

  5. Follow-up: phased pruning plan for large/old hardwoods.

Need emergency tree service?

Call 585-201-8533 — we’re 24/7.

Town service page: Tree Service in Pittsford, NY

Nearby towns: Fairport, NY, Brighton, NY